Skip to main navigation Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to search
Skip to content
Hours & Location, opens an overlay Help Help, opens an overlay
Hours & LocationsHours & Locations, collapsed
See all locations
HelpHelp, collapsed
  • Ask Us
  • FAQs
  • Get a Library Card
  • About HCPL
  • Catalog and Account Guide
Admin AdminAdmin, collapsed
Log In / My HCPL
  • Log In / Register
  • My Library Dashboard
  • My Borrowing
  • Checked Out
  • On Hold
  • Borrowing History
  • Fees
  • ILL Requests
  • My Collections
  • For Later Shelf
  • Completed Shelf
  • In Progress Shelf
  • Lists
  • My Events
  • My Profile
  • My Settings
Harris County Public Library
Main navigation Events
Open search form
Search the
by
for
    Saved Searches Advanced Search

    Search

    by
    for
      Saved Searches Advanced Search
      • BrowseBrowse, collapsed

        Browse

        • Catalog
        • Overdrive/Libby
        • Explore hcpl.net

        BY AUDIENCE

        • Kids
        • Teens
        • Adults

        BY FORMAT

        • Books
        • eBooks
        • Audio
        • Movies & TV
        • Magazines & Newspapers

        RECOMMENDATIONS

        • Coming Soon
        • New Titles
        • Award Winners
        • Bestsellers
        • Explore

        MORE

        • About HCPL
        • Blog
        • Careers @ HCPL
        • Friends of the Library
        • Library Policies
        • Newsroom
        • Podcast
        • Suggest a Book
        • Volunteer
      • EventsEvents, collapsed

        Events

        • All Events
        • Monthly Calendar

        BY AUDIENCE

        • Kids
        • Teens
        • Adults

        FEATURED PROGRAMS

        • Asian American Pacific Islander Heritage Month
        • Authorama
        • Book Buddies
        • Easter & Pesach
        • Growing Readers
        • Gulf Coast Reads
        • Summer Reading Program

        MORE

        • Books & Reading
        • Citizenship & English Learning
        • Computers & Technology
        • Maker & STEM
        • Story Time
      • ServicesServices, collapsed

        Services

        • Get a Card
        • My Account
        • My Account Help
        • Accessibility Request

        YOUR LIBRARY

        • Adaptive Resources
        • Ask Us
        • Copying & Printing
        • Elections & Government
        • ILL (Interlibrary Loan)
        • In the Community
        • LAWPods
        • Library for All
        • Meeting & Study Rooms
        • Passport Services
        • Tax Services
        • Veterans Resources

        EDUCATION

        • Adult Literacy
        • Career Online High School
        • Citizenship
        • College & Career
        • ESL (Learn English)
        • Growing Readers (children 0-5 years)
        • HCPL Connected
        • Homeschool & Educator Resources

        FOR READERS

        • Author Alerts
        • Author Talks
        • Book Bundles
        • Book Hunters
        • Gulf Coast Reads
        • Newsletters
        • Summer Reading

        MAKER & MORE

        • Maker Central
        • Digital Media Labs
        • Innovation Labs
        • Gardening Tools
      • Online ResourcesOnline Resources, collapsed

        Online Resources

        • Online Resources
        • A-Z Resources
        • By Format
        • Apps

        BY SUBJECT

        • Books, Literature & Reading
        • Business, Finance & Legal
        • Computers & Technology
        • Digital Media
        • DIY
        • Español
        • Genealogy & History
        • Government
        • Health
        • HCPL Digital Archive
        • Job & Career
        • Language Learning & ESL
        • Lifelong Learning
        • Newspapers, Magazines & Journals
        • Reference & Research
        • Religion, Philosophy & Social Sciences
        • Science & Nature
        • Texshare

      Explore HCPL.NETExplore HCPL.NET

      Our EXPLORE page is a deep dive into library content, from blogs, reading lists, and library news, to online resources, events, services, and so much more. If you think you know everything HCPL has to offer, you owe it to yourself to explore! Filter by content type, format, genre, topic, and age range.

      Our EXPLORE page is a deep dive into library content! From blogs, reading lists, and news, to online resources, events, services, and so much more. If you think you know everything HCPL has to offer, you owe it to yourself to explore hcpl.net! Filter by content type, format, age range, genre, topic and more!

      EXPLORE EXPLORE
      • HCPL Blogs
      • Mary M
      12
      Aug 2024

      Categories

      • View all cards in Adults
      • View all cards in Arts & Entertainment
      • View all cards in Books
      • View all cards in Library for All
      • View all cards in Literature & Writing
      • View all cards in Nonfiction
      • View all cards in Social Issues & Politics

      Similar Posts for You

      • Pearl Buck’s Forgotten Love Story

        May 7, 2025

      • What Does ‘There Is No Ethical Consumption Under Capitalism’ Mean?

        May 6, 2025

      • Golems and Dybbuks and Estries, Oh My!

        May 6, 2025

      • Teachers Who Shaped Us

        May 4, 2025

      • Tales of the Unread:

        Apr 22, 2025

      Thoughts on Problematic Authors

      by Mary MAugust 12, 2024

      How do we deal with problematic writers? It’s somewhat of a timeless question. Artists of all kinds throughout have been considered controversial not for their creations but for what they have said or done that the mainstream deems out of bounds. Complicating matters, as large segments of society try to be more compassionate and inclusive, our concepts of what is controversial have changed, too. So, writers who once were seen as solidly mainstream become problematic. Still, knowing that doesn’t change what we can do about them. Here are some thoughts. 

      Separating the Art from the Artist 

      People often say they "separate the art from the artist.” That is how they can consume and, one assumes, get pleasure from art created by someone even they themselves find problematic and still rest easy. The reasoning they use is that the art that the artist created is different from the artist personally but hear me out: it is them. Before you get mad at me, let me elaborate into more than a three-word sentence that invokes the internet’s wrath.

      Anyone who has ever created any type of art knows that there is a little bit of ourselves that goes into it (which is why having access to different writers and different viewpoints is so important! #ReadBannedBooks), and there are countless interviews with actors who have played some truly awful people explaining that they found just the little bit of something to understand or relate to about their character to help them get through portraying that person.  

      Does that mean that every writer who has written anything harmful in it has then thrown their whole self into it? No, not at all.  I am simply saying that you cannot completely separate the art from the artist, no matter how hard you try. 

      But What About Writers Who Have Had Their Work Edited?

      What I have just said does not apply to Roald Dahl and Dr. Seuss because these are different situations. Dahl and Seuss are no longer alive, which means they aren’t suspiciously doubling down and arguing with people on the internet, cannot take the money they earn and donate it to causes that actively harm people, and are not continuing to perpetuate harmful rhetoric.  

      (For reference, those are all things that still-living writers J.K. Rowling and Orson Scott Card have done. GLAAD (Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation) has compile detailed timelines of both authors' public statements and actions against the LGBTQ+ community: GLAAD J.K. Rowling Timeline | GLAAD Orson Scott Card Timeline

      But back to specifically Dahl and Seuss, buying books in unedited form doesn’t currently support their views, and Dr. Seuss, for instance, even apologized for some of his more troubling work (okay, it was a partial apology). The scrubbing of books to represent the current culture isn’t always bad, either. For instance, no one is up in arms about Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None having its title changed from its original version because we all collectively know that it had A Very Bad Title (or we should all know that). Dahl’s estate decided to publish “The Roald Dahl Classic Collection,” which would be unedited, which seems like a good compromise. 

      Oh, So You’re Saying We Cancel Everyone 

      Again, an artist’s work does not necessarily represent their whole, true identity. I mean, Rowling is under fire for being exclusionary, but she still wrote a character who fights for equal rights. The point is that creative people can be problematic and still have something of value to analyze and think about. 

      So, no, I’m not saying cancel everyone (which isn't really a thing, anyway). What I am saying is that simply saying “separate the art from the artist!” is a cop-out that lets us enjoy the things we want to enjoy without critically considering what we’re consuming and, more importantly, what we’re allowing problematic artists to do and say because our consumption of the art is, in fact, supporting the artist. Are celebrities entitled to an opinion? Absolutely. Are they entitled to an opinion even if it is hurtful to others? Yes, they are. But they are not entitled to use their notoriety to amplify their opinions in the media. Don't get me wrong. They can and do do that, but they are not entitled to a larger, louder voice than anyone else. And we are absolutely entitled, if not obligated, to clap back at any hateful nonsense a celebrity may let loose on the world.

      This Blog Is Getting Long 

      Let me try to be succinct: What we allow to continue, will continue, and if, by today’s standards, we recognize that something is hateful or harmful, we probably shouldn’t continue to promote it. Of course, when we don’t promote it, people tend to think that means we’re hiding it, or banning it, or trying to get rid of it. Not sharing memes from a problematic author doesn’t mean you’re erasing their entire body of work. It simply means you’re not promoting that person knowing that their words and actions have been harmful to a whole swath of the community. 

      I also think it’s fair to point out that, though I am trying to be neutral, you can tell where I stand, so you probably can’t separate me from my work. 

      Still, keeping books in their original ugly-by-todays-standards state is a good conversation starter and offers teachable moments, but that’s not necessarily in the purview of publishing houses. They are businesses, after all, and they’re going to publish books that people will buy, whether they’re controversial or not. Are they going to publish something under the guise of teaching? Probably not. So, again, it’s up to us as a society to continue to be thoughtful and analytical about the things that we allow to stand without challenge.

      So now I will bullet point it for everyone who thinks TLDR: 

      • Publishers can and should stop publishing works that are racist, homophobic, ableist, etc. 
      • Libraries should NOT pull them from their shelves. 
      • Buying items from your (now troubling) fandom secondhand still lets you celebrate the work while not financially supporting someone who’s actively hurting a community. 
      • Not promoting does not equal canceling or erasing. 

      This is a complex subject and intelligent, thoughtful people can have wildly divergent opinions on it. Here are some books from our collection if you want to explore it further.

      Drawing the Line

      Monsters

      On Censorship

      Add a comment

      More by Mary M

      There Is No Ethical Consumption Under Capitalism

      • Adults
      • Nonfiction
      • Business & Money
      • Social Issues & Politics

      World Password Day: Tips to Protect Your Privacy and Data

      • Adults
      • Teens
      • Nonfiction
      • Computers & Technology
      • How Do I...?

      A Study in Empowerment: Women's Rights AND Wrongs

      • Adults
      • Historical Fiction
      • Nonfiction
      • Genealogy & History
      • Library for All

      Discover New Posts

      Pearl Buck's Forgotten Love Story

      • Adults
      • Classics
      • Historical Fiction
      • Culture & Travel
      • Genealogy & History

      There Is No Ethical Consumption Under Capitalism

      • Adults
      • Nonfiction
      • Business & Money
      • Social Issues & Politics

      Golems and Dybbuks and Estries, Oh My!

      • Adults
      • Teens
      • Horror
      • Culture & Travel
      • Mind, Body & Spirituality

      Add a comment to: Thoughts on Problematic Authors

      We welcome your respectful and on-topic comments and questions in this limited public forum. To find out more, please see Appropriate Use When Posting Content. Community-contributed content represents the views of the user, not those of Harris County Public Library

      Footer Menu

      More Services

      • Author Alerts
      • Catalog & Account Help
      • Suggest a Book
      • Digital Access
      • HCPL Connected
      • Maker
      • Military Library Card
      • Podcast
      • Request a Book Bundle

      FAQs

      • My Account
      • Borrowing
      • Collections
      • Copying & Printing
      • Special Equipment

      Resources

      • Digital Media
      • Reference & Research
      • Business, Finance & Legal
      • Science & Nature
      • Lifelong Learning

      About Us

      • About HCPL
      • Locations & Hours
      • Holiday Closures
      • Blogs
      • Careers
      • Get Involved
      • LibraryForAll

      Contact the Library

      Harris County Public Library
      5749 S Loop E Hwy
      Houston, TX 77033
      (713) 274-6600
      Contact Us

      Contact the Library

      Harris County Public Library
      5749 S Loop E Hwy
      Houston, TX 77033
      (713) 274-6600
      Contact Us
      Support Library , opens a new window
      Terms of Use, opens a new window Privacy Statement, opens a new window Accessibility Statement, opens a new window © 2025 Harris County Public Library

      Powered by BiblioCommons.

      BiblioWeb: webapp01 Version 4.26.1 Last updated 2025/04/27 07:55

      Back to Top